Avvo - Rate your Lawyer. Get Free Legal Advice.

Donna was born and raised in Wisconsin. After raising a family, she returned to college and graduated summa cum laude from Concordia University in 1993. She graduated from the University of Wisconsin Law School in 1995.

Since her admission to the Wisconsin Bar, she has practiced law in Wisconsin. Her son and law partner, Anthony Cotton, joined the firm in 2005. We currently have 4 attorneys in our firm specializing in all types of criminal defense. As a firm, we represent many high profile defendants.

Donna specializes in serious state felonies, federal crimes, sex crimes and in the field of child abuse including shaken baby or abusive head trauma allegations. She has a reputation for providing vigorous, high quality legal defense in complex criminal cases. She has successfully argued and won a major federal drug case in the Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals in Chicago of United States v. Fidel Robeles-Ortega, 348 F.3d 679. In addition, Donna J. Kuchler won an operating while intoxicated case at the Wisconsin Court of Appeals in State of Wisconsin v. Begicevic, 270 Wis.2d 675.

Donna J. Kuchler was awarded the Martin Hanson Award by the Wisconsin Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers on two separate occasions. This prize is awarded to those lawyers who have accomplished the rare and difficult task of winning a criminal homicide trial. Donna J.

Kuchler won this award for her successful defense in the case of State of Wisconsin v.

Dittberner, 2004 CF 147 (Jefferson County, WI). In that case, the defendant (father) was charged with shaking his infant baby and causing his death. The jury found Mr. Dittberner not guilty. She further won the award for her successful defense of a death penalty case in Ocala, Florida in the matter of State of Florida v. Rishi Ramgoolie which concluded in March 2014. In that case, the defendant was charged with killing his infant niece. The defense was successful in showing that the Medical Examiner was negligent and that numerous State experts missed problems with this baby which explained her death. The verdict was a resounding not guilty.

In 2014 Donna was given the prestigious William Coffey Memorial Award for exceptional contributions to professionalism in the field of criminal justice. She was named a leading lawyer in Wisconsin in 2015 and also a leading woman in law in 2014.

Donna practices in every county in Wisconsin and elsewhere in the United States on a pro hoc vice basis. She frequently works as a consultant for attorneys around the country who are defending an abusive head trauma (AHT) or shaken baby (SBS) case. She has frequently lectured on the subject at continuing legal education conferences. She attends the National and International conferences on child abuse. Because child abuse cases often involve sensational allegations which must be objectively examined, she believes that it is critical to keep abreast of the most current medical, scientific and psychological research and studies.

Donna has been successful in numerous jury trials throughout the State of Wisconsin, maintaining an acquittal average significantly higher than her colleagues. She has won acquittals on homicides, felony drug delivery/manufacture, child abuse, reckless endangerment, disorderly conduct, substantial battery, burglary, operating while intoxicated, PAC charges, child neglect, bail jumping, possession of controlled substances, among others.

If you want an attorney who will pay attention to your case; who is willing to invest the time and energy into your defense; and who has an outstanding reputation, please give Donna a call or email her at [email protected]




Areas of PracticeCriminal Law, Constitutional Law, DUI/DWI, Divorce, Family Law, Litigation & Appeals, Motor Vehicle Accidents (Plaintiff), Personal Injury (Plaintiff), Social Security (Disability), Traffic Violations, White Collar Crimes, Workers' Compensation Law
Honors and AwardsAwarded prestigious Martin Hanson Award (2005, 2014), David Niblack Award (2010), Leading Lawyers in Wisconsin (2013), William Coffey Memorial Award (2014), Women in the Law (2014)
Bar AdmissionsWisconsin (1996), U.S. District Court Eastern District of Wisconsin (1996), U.S. District Court Western District of Wisconsin (1996), U.S. Court of Appeals 7th Circuit (1997)
MembershipsWisconsin Bar Association (Member), Wisconsin Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers (Member), National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers (Member), American Bar Association (Member), Association of Trial Lawyers of America (Member)


J.D.University of Wisconsin, Madison, Wisconsin, 1995
B.A.Concordia University, Mequon, Wisconsin, 1993
HonorsSumma Cum Laude
MajorBusiness Administration